Cannibal: The Musical

• Alferd Packer (Trey Parker/Topher Mauerhan/ Jason Lythgoe): The protagonist; a naive, optimistic guide who falls in love with his horse and gets lost in the mountains.

• Polly Pry (Toddy Walters/Kari C. Kennedy/ Alyssa Burnett): A smart, determined reporter who believes in Packer's innocence and falls in love with him.

• Shannon Wilson Bell (Ian Hardin/Ryan Young/ Conor Sheehan): The primary antagonist among the miners; aggressive, cynical, and eventually becomes a murderous threat.

• George "California" Noon (Dian Bachar/Andrew Manzani/Tabatha Bettin): A young, inexperienced miner who is searching for gold and is desperate to lose his virginity.

• Frank Miller (Jason McHugh/J. Mel Jarnagin/ Mitchell Dorsk): The leader of the group who quickly loses his patience with Packer.

• James Humphrey (Matt Stone/Ricky Augustin/ Liam Hahn): A miner who frequently questions Packer's leadership.

• Israel Swan (Jon Hegel/Reggie Koffman/Riki Tsethlikai): The optimistic, singing member of the group.

• Frenchy Cabazon (Robert Muratore/Nick Emmett Mcgee/Mark Palmer): A French trapper who is dating Liane.

Supporting & Ensemble

• Liane (Duster/Sabrina Zellers/Min Bucheger): Packer’s fickle love interest who leaves him for Frenchy.

• The Cyclops (Edward Henwood/Kevin J. Garcia/ Amy Des Forge): A one-eyed, menacing mountain dweller.

• Nihonjin Chief (Masao Maki/Junichi/Tomomi): Leader of the local Japanese Indians who teaches Packer combat skills.

• Judge Jerry (Randy Parker): The presiding judge at Packer's trial.

• Trappers/Townsfolk: Various roles including miners, Native Americans, and members of the court.